He Wore That Jersey?! MLB Players You Forgot Played On Random Teams

These days, it’s pretty hard for an athlete to change teams without getting a lot of attention. Thanks in large part to social media cycles and breaking news around the clock on television, we hear ab

These days, it’s pretty hard for an athlete to change teams without getting a lot of attention. Thanks in large part to social media cycles and breaking news around the clock on television, we hear about any athlete that switches teams. For crying out loud, Timofey Mozgov’s signing with the Lakers was big news in the summer of 2016.

Players move around a lot in baseball, with the trade deadline in the middle of the season being one of the most active in all of the four major sports in the United States. Offseason signings for guys that were considered washed up or deemed too injured to play for big contracts have signed for some pretty random teams throughout the years. Just look at guys like Ivan Rodriguez (Yankees, Astros, Nationals), Kerry Wood (Yankees, Indians) or Nomar Garciaparra (Cubs, Dodgers) in recent years that you probably forgot about.

Then there are those players that joined some really random teams, to the point where the jerseys and trading cards that were printed have since become high valued collectors items. Here are the top 15 players that wore random jerseys that you probably won’t be finding in stores, but can make some good cash if you do.

15 Anthony Rizzo


In 2007, Anthony Rizzo was selected by the Red Sox in the sixth round of the MLB Draft. Unfortunately, Rizzo was diagnosed with Hodgkin’s Lymphoma the next year, but bounced back to become a solid prospect. Rizzo was dealt to the Padres after the 2010 season with three other players for Adrian Gonzalez. Rizzo made 49 appearances for San Diego, batting just .141 with one home run.

Rizzo was then quietly dealt to the Cubs as part of the Andrew Cashner trade and he has been a mainstay in the lineup ever since. Rizzo struggled at first, but he has been an All Star in the past three seasons, hitting more than 30 home runs in each of those years. Rizzo is batting .273 in his five seasons with the Cubs and has mashed 132 home runs, and he only continues to get better as the Padres are kicking themselves.

14 John Smoltz


Michigan native John Smoltz was drafted by the local Detroit Tigers, but was traded to the Braves before making his Major League debut. In 1988, Smoltz would get his chance and played with the Braves all the way through the 2008 season with the exception of the 2000 season due to Tommy John surgery. Smoltz made eight All Star Game appearances and racked up a record of 210-147 with a 3.26 ERA in his 20 seasons in Atlanta.

Even though it wasn’t all that long ago, you might not remember that Smoltz actually ended his career after 2009 with a pair of teams. Smoltz signed with the Red Sox for the 2009 season, but was then released in August after declining to go to the minors. He then signed with the Cardinals, posting a 1-3 record with a 4.26 ERA. Unsurprisingly, Smoltz retired after the season.

13 Trevor Hoffman

Otto Greule /Allsport

One of the greatest relief pitchers of all-time, Trevor Hoffman posted 601 saves in his illustrious career and an impressive ERA of 2.87. You will, of course, remember that Hoffman played most of his career with the Padres. When he went to the Brewers in 2009, people were a bit surprised that he wouldn’t spend his entire career with San Diego, but what they didn’t know is that the Padres weren’t even his first Major League team.

That distinction actually belongs to the Miami (then Florida) Marlins, who selected the former college shortstop as part of the 1992 MLB Expansion Draft. Hoffman played part of the 1993 season with the Marlins before being shipped to San Diego. While in Miami, Hoffman posted a 2-2 record with two saves and a 3.28 ERA.

12 Dwight Gooden


As a 19 year old that debuted with the New York Mets in 1984, many people thought that Dwight Gooden had the chance to become one of the greatest pitchers of all-time. He certainly looked like it at first, reaching four All Star Games in his first five seasons. Gooden would remain with the Mets until 1994 until he was suspended for the entire 1995 season. The attention was still on Gooden, who signed with the Yankees upon his return.

After not being very effective with the Yankees, Gooden joined the Cleveland Indians where he enjoyed some decent success. However, he would fall off of the map in 1999 and people stopped paying attention. That’s why you probably forgot that before returning to the Yankees for one last foray in 2000, he had actually spent time with the Astros and Devil Rays earlier that year before being cut by both teams, but he did end with a World Series ring.

11 Reggie Jackson


People remember the famous afro and the young talent of Reggie Jackson when he was with the Athletics organization when they made the move from Kansas City to Oakland. We all also remember when he became Mr. October as a member of the Yankees, winning two World Series rings with the team (bringing his total to five). He then ended his career after five seasons with the Angels and one last fling in Oakland.

The year that gets glossed over in the Reggie Jackson history books, though, is his one season in Baltimore in 1976. There were 13 All Star appearances for Jackson in a 14 year span and 1976 was the only time he didn’t make it. Jackson had a solid season batting .277 with 27 home runs and 91 runs batted in, but it was like he was invisible playing in Baltimore.

10 Yogi Berra


Another player that will always be fondly remembered as one of the great Yankees of all-time, Yogi Berra is perhaps the greatest catcher to ever play. Berra made his Yankees debut in 1946 and appeared to be a lifer after making every All Star Game between 1948 and 1962. 1963 saw limited playing time for Berra, who retired at the age of 38 and didn’t play in the 1964 season. However, Berra would manage the Yankees during that season.

The next year, Berra was on the Mets coaching staff and came out of retirement to play four games for the team. Berra had two hits in his nine career at-bats with the Mets, striking out three times. Berra remained on the Mets coaching staff until 1975, rejoining the Yankees in 1976.

9 Harmon Killebrew


Before the steroid era came into baseball, Harmon Killebrew was easily one of the best power hitters that the sport had ever seen. The 11-time All Star led the American League in home runs six times and he became a member of the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1984. Killebrew made his debut with the Washington Senators, who would later become the Minnesota Twins. For 20 years, Killebrew remained with the same franchise.

Due to declining skills at an older age, the Twins were ready to part ways with Killebrew. He opted to leave instead of being sent to AAA and he would join the Kansas City Royals for his final year in baseball. Sadly, Killebrew’s age would show in that one year away from the Twins franchise as he batted just .199 with 14 home runs over 106 games.

8 Wade Boggs


Casual baseball fans mostly know that Wade Boggs was a memorable player for the Boston Red Sox for a decade and then continued his great career with the Yankees in the mid 90s. For 12 straight years that spanned over his time in Boston and New York, Boggs made the American League All Star team. After that, you are more likely to remember Boggs getting into a bar fight with town drunk Barney Gumble on The Simpsons or even the episode of It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia where the gang tries to pound beers before you remember his other Major League stint.

In 1998, Boggs signed with the Tampa Bay Devil Rays and had the franchise’s first home run. It was also there that Boggs collected his 3,000th career hit. His time in Tampa is something we always forget until we see a highlight of that milestone hit and thank the baseball gods that Tampa Bay has changed their uniforms.

7 Randy Johnson


When it came to intimidating pitchers, “The Big Unit” Randy Johnson was about as scary as they come. At 6’10”, Johnson was a power pitcher that was consistently getting over 100 miles per hour on his fastball. Johnson came up with the Montreal Expos (which a lot of people actually forget) until he was traded to the Mariners. Seattle made Johnson famous, but he also had memorable stops with the Diamondbacks and Yankees.

Not only were the Expos a random team for Johnson, but he also ended his career with the Giants in a forgettable season. The one that really stands out, though, is his days with the Astros. Johnson was traded from Seattle to Houston during the 1998 season where he dominated with a 10-1 record and 1.28 ERA. When he joined the Diamondbacks the next season, his time with Houston was forgotten.

6 Hank Aaron


Making it to 21 All Star Games in a row is something that we will probably never see again and, with steroids mostly out of baseball, we probably aren’t going to be seeing someone eclipse 755 home runs either. Hank Aaron did both of those things throughout the 1950s, 60s and 70s, though, making him one of the greatest players of all-time. Aaron was with the Braves in 1954 and was still on the team when they moved to Atlanta in 1966.

1974 would mark Aaron’s final season with the Braves franchise as he returned to a city he was familiar with (Milwaukee) via trade. Since 733 of his 755 home runs were with the Braves (and that memorable highlight of him breaking Babe Ruth’s record), we always associate Aaron as a lifelong Brave.

5 Mike Piazza


Considered to be one of the best hitting catchers to play in the Major Leagues, Mike Piazza became a big star in the 1990s as a member of the Los Angeles Dodgers. Then in the late 90s/early 2000s, over the span of eight seasons, Piazza was a member of the Mets where he was just as popular as ever. In the twilight of his career, he played one season each with the Padres and Athletics, providing some decent batting statistics still as he neared 40 years old.

Though San Diego and Oakland provided us with random Piazza jerseys, the most valuable one has to be the Marlins Piazza jersey. Piazza was traded to Florida with Todd Zeile for five players including Gary Sheffield and Bobby Bonilla. Seven days later, Piazza was traded to the Mets, making it one of the shortest stints in baseball history, especially for a Hall of Fame player.

4 Willie Mays


When bringing up the greatest baseball player argument, a lot of the sport’s historians talk about “The Say Hey Kid” Willie Mays. Mays put up monstrous numbers with 3,283 career hits, 660 home runs and 1,903 runs batted in while stealing 338 bases. Mays won a Rookie of the Year Award and had 19 All Star appearances with the Giants as they moved from New York to San Francisco.

Even though Mays moved with the team, he would not end his career in San Francisco, instead finishing where it all started. Mays was 41 years old when he was traded back to New York to play for the Mets in a stint that has been forgotten in baseball history. Mays played in just 135 games over two seasons for the Mets, batting .238 with 14 home runs and 44 runs batted in.

3 Manny Ramirez


Despite collecting more than 2,500 base hits and a total of 555 home runs, Manny Ramirez is always known for being a larger than life personality. The former Rookie of the Year made a huge splash in the 1990s with the Indians as he helped the team make it to the 1997 World Series. In 2001, Ramirez joined the Red Sox where he won two World Series titles. Even with the Dodgers from 2008-2010, Ramirez enjoyed success.

Ramirez fell out of favor with Los Angeles in 2010 and was waived by the team. What happened next was Ramirez being placed into two uniforms that were completely random. Ramirez was claimed by the White Sox in 2010, playing in just 24 games. In 2011, Ramirez became a member of the Rays, but retired during the first week of the season when he started 1-for-17 and four strikeouts (and was facing a 100-game suspension).

2 Pete Rose


Whether you like him or not (or even believe him or not), Pete Rose is the all-time hits leader in Major League Baseball history. Rose came up with the Reds in 1963 and played through the 1978 season. Rose would win two titles with the team before departing to Philadelphia where he made four All Star appearances in his five seasons (and had 17 total). Rose would end his career with Cincinnati, but there was one stop in between that’s frequently forgotten.

Rose joined the Montreal Expos after the 1983 season where he would end up getting his 4,000th career hit. After just 95 games, Rose was traded back to the Reds for Tom Lawless. Rose was named a player-manager in Cincinnati where he would play until the 1986 season. His managerial career with the Reds would last until 1989 when he was banned from baseball.

1 Babe Ruth


“The Sultan of Swat,” “The Bambino” or simply “The Babe,” whatever you wanted to call him, many would call him the greatest to ever trot onto a baseball diamond. Babe Ruth set just about every record in baseball during his time, including home runs, RBIs, walks and more (though some would eventually be broken). While his most memorable years were with the Yankees, people still know that he was a member of the Red Sox first thanks to the “Curse of the Bambino.”

What most people assume, however, is that Ruth retired as a Yankee. In fact, he would return to Boston to end his career, but it was with the Braves. Ruth played in 28 games in that final 1935 season, but he batted a paltry .181 with six home runs. He knew that he was done and decided to retire early in the season, ending his great career.

Give TheSportster a Thumbs up!

Looking for an AD FREE EXPERIENCE on TheSportster?

Get Your Free Access Now!

More in MLB

He Wore That Jersey?! MLB Players You Forgot Played On Random Teams