Top 15 Worst MLB Signings In Recent Memory

Every Major League Baseball team wants to have a top player on their roster. Star players help a struggling fan base grow or help a team reach the postseason. Over the past 15 years teams throughout the league have spent a fortune on free agents. However the giant investment doesn't guarantee results like a brand new car or a working furnace. The harsh truth is a majority of the massive contracts that are issued by ball clubs end up being busts.

There are a few reasons why teams often regret giving players large scale contracts. One reason is they grant these giant signings in the later part of players careers when productivity has gone down.

Another reason could be an unfavorable environment. It's not uncommon that good players are drafted and developed by a small market team. When the player is due for a large contract the small market team can rarely keep them. Though the player receives the enormous deal the big lights in a large market like New York or Los Angeles may have a negative impact on the player who was used to a small market environment.

The final reason why large scale contracts can backfire is due to poor team chemistry. Superstars are great to have on a roster. However when someone is told they're the best by everyone they'll ultimately believe it, even if their production falls short of expectations. Having an arrogant player on the roster whose overpaid can destroy team chemistry and take away the focus from the number one goal: winning.

The following are the top 15 worst MLB signings in recent memory

Continue scrolling to keep reading

Click the button below to start this article in quick view

Start Now

15 C.J. Wilson

Richard Mackson-USA TODAY Sports

The Anaheim Angels certainly weren't messing around entering the 2012 season, just hours after they signed Albert Pujols to a 10-year deal they signed pitcher C.J. Wilson to a five-year $77.5 million contract.

Wilson was labeled the best number two starter in the league following ace Jered Weaver in the pitching rotation. In his first two seasons he won 30 games. Since then he's been nothing but a liability. In 2015 Wilson pitched only 21 games, in mid-season he had a shoulder injury and has been on the DL ever since.

The Halos are paying Wilson nearly $20 million in 2016, a season where he will watch entirely from the bench recovering from surgery.

14 Jacoby Ellsbury

Anthony Gruppuso-USA TODAY Sports

It was clear the Boston Red Sox weren't going to give center fielder Jacoby Ellsbury a contract extension. Instead he took his talents to their arch rival, the New York Yankees.

The Bronx Bombers welcomed the former All-Star with a seven-year contract worth $153 million dollars. The Yankees planned to groom Ellsbury for the leadoff spot after Derek Jeter retired at the end of the season.

Though Ellsbury hit over .270 in his first season, he's been riddled with injury. In 2015 he missed over 40 games due to a lingering knee injury. The outfielder earns near $22 million annually from the deal and will probably miss a lot more time battling injuries.

13 Matt Cain

Ron Chenoy-USA TODAY Sports

The San Francisco Giants three world championships in five years was built around good pitching. In April of 2012 they inked right handed pitcher Matt Cain to a five-year extension worth over $112 million.

Cain earned his money in 2012, in June he threw a perfect game and finished the season with a record of 16-5 and earned a second World Series ring. In 2013 Cain's ERA rose to nearly 5.00 and finished the season with a record of 8-10. Since 2013 Cain has won five games.

In 2014 he underwent elbow surgery. Since going under the knife he's attempted to battle his way back earning over $20 million a year doing so.

12 Joey Votto

Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

After Cincinnati Reds first basemen Joey Votto won NL MVP in 2010 is was clear the team wanted to make him a part of their future. Just two years later the organization signed him to a 10-year $225 million contract extension.

However little did they know the deal that would pay the first basemen through 2024 would be a mistake the team would later regret. Since 2011 Votto hasn't hit over 100 RBI's. In fact in 2012 he hit 56, nearly half what he produced the season before.

Votto's playing time has been sporadic because of injury. It seems that every other year he misses nearly half the season recovering from injury. The once MVP will likely continue this trend over the next seven seasons.

11 Anibal Sanchez

Brad Mills-USA TODAY Sports

The Miami Marlins dumped salary in 2012 by trading players all over the major league. One trade was Anibal Sanchez to the Detroit Tigers. Sanchez helped the Tigers reach the World Series that year but were swept by the San Francisco Giants.

The Tigers expressed interest in keeping Sanchez but at far too high a price. That offseason they signed him to a five-year $80 million contract. In his first year Sanchez went 14-8 with an ERA of 3.43, but lost in the ALCS to the Boston Red Sox.

Sanchez hasn't found his niche in the Motor City since then. Over the past three seasons he's won 21 games and ERA has steadily risen to nearly 7.00.

10 Ryan Howard

Bill Streicher-USA TODAY Sports

One thing that teams loathe is paying a player more than $20 million a year when the team is absolutely horrendous. The Philadelphia Phillies experienced this first hand when they signed Ryan Howard to a five-year $125 million contract extension.

The first basemen hits a lot of home runs but he does strike out - a lot. In addition to his strikeout to home run ratio he also has spent a large amount of time on the DL. In 2015 the Phillies offered to pay half of his remaining $50 million owed to him to any team that would take him in a trade.

9 Ricky Nolasco

Jennifer Buchanan-USA TODAY Sports

Heading into the 2014 season the Minnesota Twins were in desperate need of quality pitching. It seemed they lost their minds when they signed veteran pitcher Ricky Nolasco to a four-year contract worth nearly $50 million.

Nolasco's reputation of an inconsistent starter followed him his entire career, Minnesota was no different. In his first two years he won 11 games and carries an ERA close to 6.00. In 2015 he started in only eight games while serving multiple DL stints.

8 Matt Garza

Rick Scuteri-USA TODAY Sports

Since leaving the Tampa Bay Rays in 2010 Matt Garza's career has gone downhill. Therefore is was a shock when the Milwaukee Brewers signed the veteran right handed pitcher to a four-year $52 million contract.

Garza earns more than $12 million per season but has fallen way short of team expectations as a projected ace in the rotation. In his first season he finished with a record of 8-8 and held average ERA of 3.64.

Garza was eventually benched for his poor performance and the team wanted to give younger starters an opportunity. Garza publicly criticized the move. He's currently finishing a stint on the DL and will soon return as an incompetent starter.

7 Matt Holliday 

Billy Hurst-USA TODAY Sports

When the St. Louis Cardinals acquired outfielder Matt Holliday in a mid-season trade with the Oakland Athletics they hoped he would help them get back to the Fall Classic.

In the 63 games Holliday played with the Cardinals he batted .353. That offseason they brought him back on a lucrative contract, $120 million over seven years. Since being traded to St. Louis Holliday's production has dropped. The once .300 hitter barely bats his weight each season.

In 2016 Holliday will reach the final year of the deal. Earning more than $16 million annually, he will most likely be bought out instead of taking up another roster spot.

6 Jayson Werth

Eric Hartline-USA TODAY Sports

For years the Washington Nationals were at the bottom of the major leagues in every category. In the 2011 season they aimed to change that by signing veteran outfielder Jayson Werth to a seven-year deal worth $126 million.

The power hitter had just come off a successful stint with the Philadelphia Phillies where he appeared in two consecutive World Series in 2009 and 2010. To draw a crowd the Nats added Werth to the roster, only the production he had in Philly was nowhere close to what he displayed in D.C.

In his first year he batted on .232 with 58 RBI's, which was quite a steep decline from his days in the city of brotherly love. Werth continues to take up a roster spot as the highest paid player.

5 Troy Tulowitzki

Kevin Sousa-USA TODAY Sports

The Colorado Rockies wanted to make Troy Tulowitzki a franchise player. So much so they signed him to a six-year contract extension when he still had three years remaining on his current deal.

Though the shortstop demonstrated leadership traits like Derek Jeter and Cal Ripken Jr. he failed to stay healthy. Since 2012 he's missed nearly 100 games each season. In 2015 the Rockies traded their beloved player to the Toronto Blue Jays in a multi-player deal.

In 2016 Tulowitzki was benched for his poor performance. The former All-Star was batting under .180 and is making $20 million a year. The Blue Jays will continue to pay his remaining salary for the next four seasons.

4 Pablo Sandoval

Steve Mitchell-USA TODAY Sports

After Pablo Sandoval won three World Series Championships with the San Francisco Giants he tested the free agent market and cashed in. The Boston Red Sox would be the new home for the slugger when they gave him a five-year contract worth $90 million.

Sandoval reported to training camp overweight and his production fell. The slugger who hit over 20 home runs a year hit 10 in his first season with the Red Sox. In 2016 he again reported to camp overweight and was benched. Just a month into the season he required season ending shoulder surgery.

3 Prince Fielder

Troy Taormina-USA TODAY Sports

The Detroit Tigers showed the rest of the league they were all business in 2012 when they signed Milwaukee Brewers first basemen Prince Fielder to a nine-year contract worth $214 million.

In his first season Fielder hit 30 home runs and more than 100 RBIs. However in the postseason his performance was non-existent. He hit just over .200 in the playoffs and the Tigers were swept by the San Francisco Giants in the World Series.

After Fielder hit under .200 in the 2013 playoffs he was traded to the Texas Rangers. In 2014 he required season ending neck surgery. The Rangers will pay Fielder roughly $24 million a year through 2019.

2 Carl Crawford

Nick Turchiaro-USA TODAY Sports

It was rare that the Tampa Bay Rays would keep any of their superstars when they became eligible free agents because of their small payroll. Outfielder Carl Crawford cashed in when the Boston Red Sox gave him a seven-year $142 million contract.

Crawford was viewed as a bust instantly in Boston. In his first month of the season he hit .137 and was heckled more than opposing teams. In 2013 he was traded to the Los Angeles Dodgers in a multi-player deal.

Crawford was often benched in L.A. because of their plethora of outfielders. Crawford never had a season where he hit over 10 home runs and in 2016 was released by the Dodgers after hitting just over .180.

1 Josh Hamilton

Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports

Josh Hamilton had really been to hell and back because of his struggle with addiction. After the 2012 season, the outfielder's contract with the Texas Rangers ended and he was sure to re-sign. When he demanded too much money he went to the Anaheim Angels on a five-year deal worth $125 million.

Hamilton struggled on his new team as his power plummeted from his days with the Rangers. He hit only 21 home runs in 2013, a steep decline from the season earlier where he hit 43.

In 2015 Hamilton relapsed and was traded back to Texas. Anaheim showed their displeasure with Hamilton's actions by agreeing to take on the remaining $75 million of his salary. In 2016 Hamilton had season ending knee surgery.

More in MLB