Yankee Greats: Top 15 Hottest Women Alex Rodriguez And Derek Jeter Hooked Up With

Alex Rodriguez and Derek Jeter are two of the most high-profile New York Yankees Stars in recent memory.

Derek Jeter was the face of the franchise for two decades. During his tenure, the Yankees captured an impressive five World Series Championships, while Jeter earned himself  the nickname "Mr. November." He is one of the most popular players in the team's extensive history and will almost certainly be enshrined in the Hall of Fame at some point in the near future.

Alex Rodriguez had already established himself as on of baseball's brightest stars when the Yankees acquired him via trade during the 2004 season. Rodriguez had some very productive years with the team but never had the connection with the fan base that Jeter had. This was due in part to opting out of his contract in 2007 and being suspended for his role in the infamous Biogenesis baseball scandal.

While fans may have a very different opinion of the two men, there is one thing they can certainly agree on: both Derek Jeter and Alex Rodriguez know how to score both on and off the field. Between the two of them, they have been romantically linked to seemingly every, actress, model, and pop star on the planet.  With that in mind, let's take a look at the 15 hottest women who hooked up with either Derek Jeter or Alex Rodriguez.

Continue scrolling to keep reading

Click the button below to start this article in quick view

Start Now

15 Adriana Lima

Adriana Lima is a Brazilian model who is best known as a Victoria's Secret Angel. The five-foot-10 beauty is also known for being outspoken regarding her religious beliefs. The devout Roman Catholic made headlines when she told GQ magazine that "Sex is for after marriage." She would go on to marry NBA player Marko Jaric. However, the couple divorced in 2016.

Prior to meeting Jaric, Adriana Lima was rumored to have dated Derek Jeter for a couple months back in 2006. Apparently, the relationship was short-lived. It's unclear if Lima's vow of chastity came into play regarding the couple's split. At any rate, spending time with Lima in any capacity is an opportunity most men would kill for. Adriana Lima is yet another name that can be added to the impressive list of females associated with the former Yankees star.

14 Cameron Diaz

via pinterest.com

Cameron Diaz is a stunning A-list actress who starred in such films as The Mask and Bad Teacher. She has been nominated for a Golden Globe Award on four separate occasions. Prior to becoming an actress, Diaz actually started her career as a model. She modeled for companies like Levi's, Calvin Klein and even Coca-Cola. At age 44, Cameron Diaz remains one of the hottest actresses in Hollywood.

Alex Rodriguez and Cameron Diaz dated for roughly a year and a half before splitting up in 2011. Apparently, the decision to part ways was a mutual one. When asked about the relationship, Rodriguez told People;"I have a lot of love for Cameron. We'll always be friends." It sounds like the two parted ways on good terms.

13 Minka Kelly

via pinterest.com

Mika Kelly first gained mainstream notoriety for playing everyone favorite cheerleader Layla Garrity on the hit TV show Friday Night Lights. From there she would go to star in films like The Roommate and Parenthood. While Kelly may not be quite as famous as some of the other ladies on the list, she is certainly every bit as beautiful.

Derek Jeter and Minka Kelly dated on and off for several years. The couple got together sometime in 2008. There were even engagement rumors swirling around the pair during their courtship. The couple attempted to keep the relationship as low-profile as possible, though they appear to have broken up for good in 2012. As with seemingly every celebrity couple that breaks up, the two allegedly remain friends.

12 Madonna

via pinterest.com

Madonna Louise Ciccone is one of the most accomplished entertainers of her generation. She burst onto the music scene in the early 1980s with hits like "Holiday" and "Borderline." While other '80s artists have struggled to stay relevant, Madonna has been on top for nearly four decades. The pop icon also has an impressive dating resume that would easily warrant an article on the topic.

Despite being over 15 years his elder, the pop cougar may have hooked up with Alex Rodriguez in 2008. In fact, according to People.com, A-Rod's wife at the time left him over his alleged affair with the singer. The two claimed to be just friends. Though it's a bit unclear what the actual nature of their relationship was, A-Rod was linked to other women by 2009, suggesting their time together had ended.

11 Mariah Carey

via Mirror.co.uk

Mariah Carey is one of the most accomplished singers of all-time. In fact, the pop diva has sold over 200 million records. She has won countless music awards including five Grammys. Moreover, the 48-year-old starlet still looks amazing, despite being nearly half a century old.

Back in the late 1990s,  Derek Jeter and Mariah Carey were an item for roughly a year. Carey was technically still married to music mogul Tommy Mottola. Jeter was in the early stages of his professional career during this period. Apparently, Carey and Jeter couldn't handle the dating spotlight. The couple cited "media attention" as the main reason for breaking up in 1998. They were together so long ago that many of their newer fans may not have even realized the two were ever a couple.

10 Torrie Wilson

Torrie Wilson is a fitness model who is best known for her time with World Wrestling Entertainment. The native of Boise, Idaho spent nearly a decade in the professional wrestling business. She has appeared on the cover of Playboy on two separate occasions. The 41-year-old blonde bombshell is one of the hottest females to ever set foot inside a wrestling ring.

Torrie Wilson and Alex Rodriguez dated for somewhere in the neighborhood of four years between 2011-2015. According to Page Six, the two split because Rodriguez was unwilling to commit. It was also rumored that Wilson didn't care for the fact that Rodriguez was still close with his ex-wife. In typical celebrity couple fashion, the two claim to still be friends. Torrie Wilson is apparently single, for those out there who may be interested.

9 Jennifer Lopez

via bellanaija.com

The 47-year-old Puerto Rican pop star is known for both her ample backside and sizzling dance moves. Jennifer Lopez started out as a Fly Girl (dancer) on the hit comedy show In Living Color, back in 1991. Since that time, Lopez has sold $80 million worth of records. Moreover, she is also an actress whose films have grossed nearly $3 billion worldwide.

J-Lo is rich, beautiful and talented, so it's easy to see how she caught the eye of former Yankee's third baseman Alex Rodriguez. In fact, the two are currently an item. Like Rodriguez, Lopez also boasts an impressive resume of exes which include pop star Marc Anthony. The two have apparently been dating for several weeks and Lopez recently visited A-Rod at his home in Miami. It will be interesting to see how long this romance lasts.

8 Scarlett Johansson

via pinterest.com

Scarlett Johansson is another A-list star who finds herself on our list. She was the highest grossing actress of 2016 with her films bringing in a whopping $1.2 billion. It's rare these days to see any sort of list that features "world's hottest women" which doesn't feature Scarlett Johansson. There is no question that the 32-year-old New Yorker is currently one of the sexiest women in all of Hollywood.

Back in 2004, Scarlett Johansson and Derek Jeter were rumored to be an item. Despite being seen dining together and attending a holiday party, the two denied rumors that they were a couple. While the nature of their relationship was never confirmed, the two appearing in public together generated a great deal of publicity back in the day.

7 Kate Hudson

via thatgirlsgotanappetite.com

Kate Hudson first stole America's heart as Penny Lane in the hit film Almost Famous. She is also the daughter of Hollywood legend Goldie Hawn and singer Bill Hudson. The 37-year-old Los Angeles, native co-founded a fitness brand known as Fabletic and doesn't look too bad modeling the company's attire either.

Kate Hudson had a highl- publicized relationship with Alex Rodriguez in 2009. Despite the fact that the break up has allegedly mutual, many rumors came out regarding exactly why the two split up. It was said that A-Rod was "clingy" and it was also implied that Hudson was only in it for publicity, though neither of these claims are necessarily credible. Hudson would go on to date musician Matt Bellamy from the band Muse. A-Rod then moved on to Cameron Diaz.

6 Hannah Davis

via mindaptiv.com

Hannah Jeter (nee Davis) is a 5-foot-10 swimsuit model from the U.S. Virgin Islands. You may remember her from the Direct TV ads featuring the model and a talking horse wondering around the tropics. Davis was also featured in the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue in 2o15.

While the 26-year-old might be the least famous person on the list, she was the one who was able to convince Derek Jeter to finally settle down. Davis even bought the former Yankees slugger a puppy for Christmas. The two were wed in July of 2016. Moreover, Hannah Davis recently announced she has pregnant with Jeter's daughter, back in February of this year. Is Derek Jeter finally ready for family life? Will Hannah Davis be able to tame the baseball star once and for all? It appears that we will soon find out.

5 Jessica Biel

via forums.bodybuilding.com

Jessica Biel became famous for playing the role of Mary Camden on the hit television series 7th Heaven. She has also starred in several major motion pictures including The A-Team and the remake of Total Recall. Biel would begin dating pop sensation Justin Timberlake in 2007 and the couple would go on to be married in 2012.

Prior to meeting Timberlake, Biel is rumored to have dated Derek Jeter for a few months back in 2006. The two were apparently spotted together on a beach in Puerto Rico. The couple appears to have separated shortly after the trip. However, Jessica Biel wouldn't be the only hottie with that name whom Jeter allegedly hooked up with. He was also linked to another famous actress, Jessica Alba. Jeter apparently had a thing for A-list actresses.

4 Jessica Alba

via pinterest.caom

Jessica Alba is an actress who was featured in such films as Fantastic Four, Entourage, and Good Luck Chuck. Back in 2001, Alba took 1st place in Maxim's Hot 100 list. During her interview for the Hot 100 list, the starlet stated; "I have to go to certain lengths to use sexuality to my advantage, while guiding people to thinking the way I want them to."Apparently, she used it to attract the attention of former Yankees shortstop Derek Jeter.

Derek Jeter and Jessica Alba dated in 2004. The relationship was very brief and it's unclear exactly why the couple eventually separated. The 35-year old Alba is currently married to a man named Cash Warren and has two daughters. Alba and Warren were wed in 2008.

3 Demi Moore

via celebuzz.com

Demi Moore was the reigning queen of the box office during the 1990s. Moore starred in such films as Ghost, Striptease, and G.I. Jane. You would be hard pressed to find an actress more in demand than she was in her prime. The stunning thespian has been involved in many high-profile relationships including her marriages to fellow movie stars Bruce Willis and Ashton Kutcher. However, she was also seen dining with A-Rod back in 2012.

Alex Rodriguez and the 54-year-old Moore were simply having dinner, so it could be just as simple as that. However, given Rodriguez's history of hooking up with older women like Madonna, Jennifer Lopez, and even Cameron Diaz, you can see why the outing received a great deal of media attention.

2 Jordana Brewster

via pinterest.com

Jordana Brewster is best known for playing Mia Toretto in the Fast and the Furious movies. You may also recognize her from films like Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning and The Invisible Circus. Besides being beautiful, Brewster is also well-educated. She graduated from Yale with B.A. in English back in 2003.

Back in 2002, Brewster was spotted getting cozy with Derek Jeter at his birthday party. The two were seen together on several occasions that same year. However, after a few months, the sightings ceased and the relationship had apparently ended. The 36-year-old Brewster went on to marry film producer Andrew Form, who she met while working on the film Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning. She now has two children and lives in Los Angeles, California.

1 Vanessa Minnillo

via fanworld.com

Vanessa Lachey (nee Minnillo) was the host of MTV's Total Request Live and a correspondent for Entertainment Tonight. Minnillo also won the title of Miss Teen USA back in 1998. She was also featured in films such as Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer and Disaster Movie.

Minnillo dated Derek Jeter on and off from 2003-2005. The two are apparently still friends but that seems to be what every celebrity couple says after they break up. There haven't been any recent photos of the two hanging out. Minnillo would go on to marry former 98 Degrees singer Nick Lachey. Minnillo and Lachey have three children together and seem to be happily married. It seems like things went well for Vanessa Minnillo Lachey after she and Jeter decided to part ways.

More in MLB