TheSportster.com

Power Ranking Every NHL Fan Base by Loyalty

The NHL has grown significantly since the 2004-05 lockout, which is impressive enough considering it wasn't even close to competing with other North American sporting juggernats like the NFL, MLB, and

The NHL has grown significantly since the 2004-05 lockout, which is impressive enough considering it wasn't even close to competing with other North American sporting juggernats like the NFL, MLB, and NBA. But here we are, with the league setting all-time highs in attendance, revenue and general fan interest.

Gary Bettman, love him or hate him, has done a phenomenal job making the NHL a more-followed sporting organization across the continent, especially in non-traditional hockey markets like Dallas, Carolina, Tampa Bay, and Nashville. As such, every NHL team has had a lot to be thrilled about, with so much to enjoy and embrace.

But to some NHL fan bases, hockey is life, and yes we're talking about places in Canada for the most part. In case you didn't know, ice hockey is a huge deal in Canada, by far the most beloved and iconic sport. It's the one game where we Canadians develop our own stars the best.

As you'll see on this list, many teams just don't bring in enough interest from their respective cities and/or states. For others, fans are around depending entirely on how well the team is doing. But the fan thing? Any fan of any team can argue how they think their respective fan bases have the most loyal in the NHL.

Well, we're going to try our best to take all arguments into account by power ranking the loyalty and passion of all NHL fan bases. Based on attendance and game atmospheres, here is a look at how they all stack up.

Note: All attendance statistics are courtesy of ESPN.com

Continue scrolling to keep reading

Click the button below to start this article in quick view

Start Now

30 Arizona Coyotes

Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports

It's hard to give the state of Arizona any credit for their loyalty. Truth be told: There is virtually no passion there. In fact, it's absolutely difficult to believe that Gary Bettman has fought so hard over the years to keep a team that can't generate a passionate audience.

The Coyotes lost the league money for years and filed for bankruptcy. Instead of moving them to a more traditional hockey market, the Coyotes will stay here until the ice melts, it seems.

Arizona has been at the very bottom of the league standings for years, further signalling they have the least amount of loyalty and passion from their fans.

29 Carolina Hurricanes

James Guillory-USA TODAY Sports

The Hurricanes energized their fan base with a Stanley Cup in 2006 and although the crowd was right behind them the whole way, that's just about all we've seen from them since. It's a shame because the state of North Carolina was a huge hockey success during their magical run.

Carolina finished last in league attendance during 2015-16, averaging just 12,203 fans a game, playing at 65.3 percent capacity, even though they fought for a playoff spot until later in the season. Like any team, there are some loyal fans and fairweather fans, but Carolina definitely doesn't have a lot of passionate ones.

28 New York Islanders

Robert Mayer-USA TODAY Sports

Yes, it was nice to see the fans at the Barclays Center go crazy when they defeated the Florida Panthers in the first-round of the 2016 playoffs, giving the Isles their first playoff series win since 1993.

But don't let that loud arena from the playoffs fool you: There isn't a lot of love for the Islanders, even though their rather rich tradition (four Stanley Cups in a row from 1980-84) is something most teams envy greatly.

The Islanders had the third worst attendance in 2015-16, and have ranked right near the bottom of the attendance list since the lockout of 2004-05. Not exactly what you'd call "passion."

27 Florida Panthers

Robert Duyos-USA TODAY Sports

Much like the Coyotes, it's increasingly questionable as to why there's an NHL team in a place where hockey isn't special. Even the three Florida NFL teams, as well as the two Florida MLB teams, struggle big-time to put fans in seats.

The Panthers aren't much better. Their magical 2015-16 campaign that saw them surprisingly win the Atlantic Division was only good enough to bring in 15,384 fans a game.

There have been rumours that this team won't be in Florida in the long-term. It's hard to think many NHL fans would hate a relocation.

26 Columbus Blue Jackets

Aaron Doster-USA TODAY Sports

To be fair to the Blue Jackets, they're still one of the younger franchises in the NHL and Rick Nash (now a New York Ranger) is the only superstar they've ever had that was truly worth watching.

The Blue Jackets have made the playoffs just twice in their history, being swept by the Detroit Red Wings in 2009 and losing to the Pittsburgh Penguins in 2014. Years of coaching and front office mismanagement has led to these fans not willing to stick around.

Nationwide Arena does get loud for the most part, but their attendance figures are always in the bottom-third of the NHL.

25 New Jersey Devils

Ed Mulholland-USA TODAY Sports

Despite Stanley Cup titles in 1995, 2000, and 2003, the state of New Jersey hasn't been loyal to a team that gave them nearly two decades worth of absolute dominance. With long-time stars Martin Brodeur, Scott Niedermayer, Scott Gomez, Scott Stevens, and Brian Gionta long gone, fans have been forced to watch a long-term rebuild instead.

Even when New Jersey made it to the Stanley Cup Final in 2011-12, they had just 15,396 fans a game and 87.4% capacity. Even when they won the Cup in 2003, they averaged just 14,858 fans a game.

24 Anaheim Ducks

Jake Roth-USA TODAY Sports

Despite being one of the Western Conference's elite teams for a decade, the Ducks just can't bring a full stadium in unless it's playoff time. It's a shame, considering they won the Stanley Cup in 2007, but also made the Conference Final in 2006 and 2015. There's no denying how successful they are.

But still, the Ducks can't attract a crowd like their California rivals do. They're constantly near the bottom-barrel of attendance. This season (Pacific Division Champions) they averaged 16,336 a game.

Last year? 16,874. As for their Stanley Cup-winning year in 2007? 16,839 per game. Where's the passion in Anaheim? Perhaps far more people care about Disneyland than the Ducks in Orange County than we thought.

23 Nashville Predators

Christopher Hanewinckel-USA TODAY Sports

We'll give the Predators fans some credit, as the attendance and overall atmosphere has skyrocketed since the 2010-11 season. Despite being in the playoffs (or at least near qualification) every year since 2003-04, their attendance should certainly have been more consistent.

They had a 99.2% average capacity per home game in 2015-16, but the numbers in 2007-08, for example, were alarming: 87.1% capacity (14,910 fans per game) while having just 13,157 fans a game in 2003-04.

As the stats show, the general Predators fan base comes and goes, but seeing how they've shown up more in the last few seasons, plus how rowdy it gets during the playoffs, their fans have definitely made a bigger name for themselves. We'll see how that sticks around in the long-run.

22 Washington Capitals

Ron Chenoy-USA TODAY Sports

It doesn't seem fair to put the Capitals this low, because since they made the playoffs in 2007-08, the Verizon Center has been electrifying and home advantage has been huge for them during the playoffs in the Alexander Ovechkin era.

Though they are having no problems selling out, or getting at least close to it, they were in the bottom-five in attendance in 2005-06 and 2007-08. They were 25th-overall in 2003-04 and 18th in 2002-03.

So yes, like many teams on our list, the passion, loyalty, and attendance seems to hinge on how well the team is doing.

21 Colorado Avalanche

Isaiah J. Downing-USA TODAY Sports

The Avalanche had what appeared to be a top-five passionate fan base in the NHL for years. At least, the first 10-or-so years when the team relocated from Quebec to the Mile High City.

Joe Sakic, Patrick Roy, Rob Blake, and Peter Forsberg put Denver on the hockey map right away and they won the Stanley Cup in 1996 and 2001, while making the playoffs every year until the end of the 2006-07 season.

After being in the top-10 in league attendance from 2000-01 to 2003-04, they dipped to 11th in 2005-06, 17th in 2007-08, 26th in 2008-09, 28th in 2009-10 (a playoff season), and have stayed in or near the bottom-third of the barrel in the 2010s. It's safe to say a large percentage of the Avs' fan base are only around for a winner.

20 Tampa Bay Lightning

Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports

With three-straight playoff years under their belts, the Lightning are getting a largely energized fan base that sounds as loud as almost any other throughout the successful times.

They've ranked in the top-10 over the past four seasons. In 2011-12, they were 13th-overall. In 2010-11, they were 18th, despite making the Eastern Conference Final that year. They were 21st-overall in 2009-10 and 2008-09.

But they were eighth-overall in 2007-08, when they were the league's worst team. It's hard to find anything more than the fact many fans are fairweather.

19 Dallas Stars

Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports

The Stars were instantly one of the NHL's biggest powerhouses once they moved to Big D in the '90s. They won the Stanley Cup in 1999 and returned to the final the following year, before falling to New Jersey.

Dallas was always right behind their team, with stars like Mike Modano, Bill Guerin, Ed Belfour, Sergei Zubov, and Brett Hull, among many others. However, after a streak of missing the playoffs every year from 2008-09 to 2012-13, attendance slipped a bit.

They went from 14th-overall in 2008-09 to 17th the following season. They then fell to 23rd in 2010-11 and all the way down to 28th in 2011-12. Then in 2012-13, they went to 21st-overall.

In 2015-16, they were 15th-overall. So yes, Dallas is a great hockey city for the most part, but when the team is playing awful, a large amount of them aren't around supporting them during the bad years.

As such, this poorly affects their rating on the list.

18 Pittsburgh Penguins

Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sports

I know the Penguins fan base stretches all across North America, but if they deserve a top-10 spot on this list, riddle me this:

How, just how, were the Pens last in league attendance in 2003-04, averaging 11,877 fans a game? Then, in 2005-06, this team was VERY close to moving to Las Vegas, until Mario Lemieux stepped in to become part owner.

You know the rest: Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin come in, the team wins the Stanley Cup in 2009 and Pittsburgh is always in the playoffs. Yes, congratulations to the loyal fans, but most of them probably weren't following the team during the bad years.

17 Los Angeles Kings

Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

Well before their Stanley Cup titles in 2012 and 2014, the post-Wayne Gretzky era wasn't friendly to the Kings, who couldn't make the playoffs for the most part and were often out of the first-round, even after they qualified.

Still, attendance has remained steady, with the team in the middle-of-the-pack in recent years. Oddly enough, the Kings went from eighth in attendance during the 2013-14 season (their second Stanley Cup) to 15th the following season. Whatever the reason, it has nothing to do with a lack of fan loyalty.

Even in the 2007-08 season when they were one of the league's worst teams, they played at a 92% capacity. The Kings don't have the most passionate fans, but they're far from bandwagoners.

16 Chicago Blackhawks

Dennis Wierzbicki-USA TODAY Sports

Yes, they've led the league in attendance every year since 2008-09, but once critical stat here doesn't lie:

The Blackhawks were second-last in NHL attendance during the 2006-07 season, when they were among the worst teams. They only averaged 12,727 fans a game and there are reports out there that 'Hawks players had to hand out free tickets to fans.

Now, the United Center is one of the loudest hockey arenas and there's nothing like the anthem in the playoffs. Blackhawks fans are always invading the opposing team's stadium when Chicago is on the road.

We give them major credit for that, but where was the loyalty during the bad years? For that, they aren't high in terms of loyalty.

15 St. Louis Blues

Jasen Vinlove-USA TODAY Sports

One of the oldest NHL franchises is awaiting its first Stanley Cup, but that's not a concern yet, because the good folks of St. Louis are staying right behind their Blues.

The atmosphere during their opening-round matchup against the Chicago Blackhawks was incredible, as the team finally didn't let their fans down in their first playoff series on the season.

Even though they were among the league's worst teams in 2009-10, they were seventh in attendance, averaging 18,883 fans a game. In 2010-11, the numbers jumped up to 19,150, also seventh in the league that year.

As for 2007-08, another disappointing year? They still had a 99.5% capacity in attendance.

14 Winnipeg Jets

Bruce Fedyck-USA TODAY Sports

The Jets have only wrapped up five seasons in the NHL, but they're selling out every home game despite making the playoffs just once (2014-15) and even then, they were swept in the opening round.

That's impressive for a city that only has about 663,000 people. The Jets haven't given their fans much to celebrate in a place that's not home to millions like most other NHL markets. Gary Bettman finally gave them their team back and the incredible fan base has given the NHL a lot to be happy about.

13 Ottawa Senators

Marc DesRosiers-USA TODAY Sports

Despite having their arena in the middle of almost nowhere, years of mediocrity and no Stanley Cup Championships, the general fan base in Canada's capital remains one of the loudest and largest league-wide.

Though the Sens don't sell out consistently, they're always playing from the mid-to-late 90 percent in capacity. But everyone knows how huge the hockey market is in Ottawa. Hockey is the biggest sport in Canada and it is only fitting the fans love their team in the nation's capital.

12 Buffalo Sabres

Kevin Hoffman-USA TODAY Sports

The Sabres are on a level with the Canucks and Sharks: They've never won a Stanley Cup and their fans have had to endure more than enough crushing defeats. Yet that's not enough for the fans to leave behind their beloved Sabres.

They averaged 18,580 fans a game in 2014-15 compared to 18,590 this year. In 2013-14, they averaged 18,579 fans a game. Why is this impressive? Because the Sabres were among the league's worst teams those three seasons.

Say what you want about the Sabres, but the fans LOVE their team, and they haven't proven to us that they'll leave anytime soon.

11 San Jose Sharks

John Hefti-USA TODAY Sports

The Sharks were a good, not great, team in the '90s and emerged as a perennial powerhouse in the 2000s and 2010s, but they never made it to the Stanley Cup Final. They've had playoff letdown after playoff letdown, but the Shark Tank is crazy every night.

San Jose actually saw a steep decline in attendance, finishing 22nd-overall in 2015-16, but they still played up to a 95.4% capacity. They were 11th-overall in 2014-15, with a 109.2 percent capacity.

Sure, it's easy to accuse the fans of drifting away, but in a season with low expectations, the Shark Tank still nearly sold out most games and the fans been loyal to their team for two decades. We're not going to overlook that.

10 Boston Bruins

Jonathan Dyer-USA TODAY Sports

If it weren't for Minnesota, Massachusetts would be the ultimate hockey state. Their college programs and teams are phenomenal, but their Bruins are the pride of hockey in the state of Massachusetts.

Despite nearly 20 years of lackluster play, the Bruins fans have filled up TD Garden for ages and they were rewarded with a Stanley Cup in 2011 for their patience (39 years without a Cup before that).

Though the Bruins missed the playoffs the last two seasons, they're having no problem selling out every night. The atmosphere is absolutely electrifying night-in and night-out in Beantown.

9 Vancouver Canucks

Anne-Marie Sorvin-USA TODAY Sports

Despite being by far the worst-managed team in the NHL over the last 10 years, the Canucks still draw great attendance at Rogers Arena. The fans deserve a lot of praise for being loyal to a team that's let them down in almost every way possible.

They're always among the top-10 in NHL attendance, but slide to 14th-overall during the 2015-16 season. That's not enough to rank them lower, because for almost 50 years, the city of Vancouver has cheered on their Canucks like few other cities.

8 Minnesota Wild

Marilyn Indahl-USA TODAY Sports

Just how important are the fans in the eyes of the Minnesota Wild franchise? How about the fact that the number one was retired for the Wild faithful once the team got their hockey team back (after the North Stars left for Dallas after the 1993 season).

The Wild haven't seen a lot of success but still, the Xcel Energy Center is packed every night, with the Wild always among the top-10 in league attendance.

To be "The State of Hockey," you better have a wide following with wild fans (pun intended) and that's what Minnesota's NHL team has.

7 New York Rangers

Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports

Even as the Rangers faithful waited 54 years without a cup (a drought from 1940-1994), the fans were right behind their team, even though there were long streaks of losing over and over again.

22 years after the Rangers last won their cup and Madison Square Garden remains one of the best places to see a hockey game and not only for its history. The fans love their Rangers so much, that the team dedicated its goal song to the Blueshirts faithful.

As an Original Six franchise, the Rangers have been crucial to New York City and times have never changed.

6 Philadelphia Flyers

Ron Chenoy-USA TODAY Sports

Philadelphia sports fans seem to have a reputation for being among the most obnoxious and arrogant in the NHL. Every team has that, but few sports teams have the loyal fans that the Flyers do.

Philadelphia hasn't won a Stanley Cup since 1975, but the fans have patiently waited. They've ranked in the top-six in NHL attendance every year since 2007-08. Few fan bases get as rowdy during the playoffs as well.

5 Detroit Red Wings

Andrew Weber-USA TODAY Sports

As the city of Detroit has had many financial problems over the years, fans have relied heavily on their beloved Red Wings to give them something to always cheer about. How about 25-straight playoff seasons and four Stanley Cup Championships?

Joe Louis Arena has always been loud. Yes, you'll often see The Joe filled with empty seats during home games, but their attendance actually ranks in the top-five every year and the arena is louder than most in the league.

Even if you watch away games, you'll see Wings fans everywhere. Fans who've left Michigan haven't left behind their love for Detroit.

4 Calgary Flames

Sergei Belski-USA TODAY Sports

The Flames fans are like every other Canadian team: they haven't seen success in years, and sometimes decades, but it hasn't stopped the fans from coming all-out to support them as if it's playoff season.

Calgary's had no problem selling out each game and ranking in the top-10 in attendance consistently. Remember the Red Mile during their 2004 run to the Stanley Cup Final? That was a sight to behold.

Fans of Calgary deserve a winning franchise and hopefully it comes sooner rather than later.

3 Edmonton Oilers

Sergei Belski-USA TODAY Sports

The Oilers fan base is so passionate that Rexall Place, which sat 16,841, was simply not enough and they'll have a new stadium in 2016-17.

Edmonton fans, who haven't seen a Stanley Cup victory since 1990 or a playoff appearance since 2006, have stuck right by their Oilers the whole way, selling out game after game even though they keep fighting for the first-overall pick.

Just re-watching their 2006 playoff run and seeing how energized the crowd was gives you the shivers. The fans live and bleed Oil colours. There's nothing more to see here.

2 Toronto Maple Leafs

John E. Sokolowski-USA TODAY Sports

Even though Toronto hasn't won a Stanley Cup since 1967 and have made the playoffs once since the lockout, the fans at the Air Canada Centre are rocking it every night, supporting their perennially-struggling Leafs.

Their ticket prices are the most expensive in the NHL by far, but that doesn't stop fans from attending games. Yes, most of the lower bowl tickets are handed out to businessmen and women looking for clients, but the upper bowl is where the passionate fans are, and they can be heard no matter how high up they are.

The Leafs fans also travel an insane amount. Any road game in Detroit or Buffalo brings in at least half Toronto fans. Most games in Florida are filled with Leafs fans. That's their passion for you.

1 Montreal Canadiens

Eric Bolte-USA TODAY Sports

There isn't a louder, more passionate or more rowdy fan base in North America than the Montreal Canadiens faithful.

At the Bell Centre, absolutely every game is as electrifying as most other teams' playoff games and that is no exaggeration. The Habs are always in the top-two in league attendance and have no problem selling games every year.

The fans have been a little over too passionate, such as getting the police to investigate the Zdeno Chara hit on Max Pacioretty in 2011, starting a riot over Maurice Richard's suspension, and much more.

But this fan base sticks behind their team like no other.

Give TheSportster a Thumbs up!

Looking for an AD FREE EXPERIENCE on TheSportster?

Get Your Free Access Now!

More in NHL

Power Ranking Every NHL Fan Base by Loyalty