There are pros and cons of being the first overall selection in any draft. Yes, you automatically stand out, get all of the media attention, and have the opportunity to save a city single handedly.
Look at recent draft picks like Sidney Crosby and Alexander Ovechkin. They came to teams with little followings and a lack of winning traditions for several years. Suddenly, they became the two biggest names in the NHL, engaged in a fierce rivalry, and have led their respective teams to prominence.
Then there are guys like Rick DiPietro, who was best remembered for signing a lucrative contact despite never being a true superstar. There's Ilya Kovalchuk who ditched the NHL in the midst of a contract that made him a $100 million man. And there's Nail Yakupov, who failed to rescue the Edmonton Oilers and will probably find a new team at some point.
But looking back 36 years ago, many draft picks changed the landscape of hockey. During the '80s and '90s, we saw a number of first overall selections become either busts, average players, useful players, superstars, legends, once-in-a-lifetime players, and Hall of Famers.
We look back now and see how some of these players changed their franchises around, for better or worse. Surely, some of these teams who drafted the wrong guy number one overall are feeling it all these years later. Warning: If you're an Ottawa Senators fan, you may not want to keep reading.
Without further ado, here's a look at our rankings of every first overall pick from 1980-1999.
Click the button below to start this article in quick view
21 Gord Kluzak, 1982
The Boston Bruins took the towering 6-foot-4 defenseman with the first pick in the 1982 draft, missing out on talents Scott Stevens and Phil Housley.
Gord Kluzak would only appear in 299 career NHL games, scoring 25 goals and 123 points, and was out of the league by 1990-91, though he did help the Bruins make the Stanley Cup Final the year before.
Brian Bellows was taken after Kluzak, with the former becoming part of the 1,000-point club.
20 Doug Wickenheiser, 1980
The cousin of Hayley, arguably the greatest women’s hockey player to ever live, Doug Wickenheiser was selected by the Montreal Canadiens with the top pick, but unfortunately never developed into the superstar they had hoped for.
His NHL career ended in 1989-90 with the Washington Capitals, appearing in 556 games. He scored 111 goals and 276 points. He sadly passed away from cancer in 1999.
19 Brian Lawton, 1983
Widely remembered as one of the biggest draft busts in NHL history, Brian Lawton was supposed to make the Minnesota North Stars a top team, bringing in a new era. But unfortunately, it never panned out as they had hoped.
Lawton could never find his full potential, with his best season being a 21-23-44 campaign in 1986-87. Lawton scored 20 goals just once in the NHL and would only appear in 483 games, scoring 112 goals and 266 points.
The following six picks after Lawton were All-Stars and two of them were Hall of Famers: Sylvain Turgeon, Steve Yzerman, Pat LaFontaine, Tom Barrasso, John MacLean, and Russ Courtnall.
18 Patrik Stefan, 1999
Sadly for Patrik Stefan, he’s best remembered as the guy who had an empty net and a breakaway to help the Dallas Stars put away a game against the Edmonton Oilers nearly a decade ago. He slipped and fell, and the Oilers went back the other way to tie the game in the final second.
Former Vancouver Canucks’ GM Brian Burke is widely regarded as a genius for getting the Atlanta Thrashers to take Stefan number one overall, allowing him to take Daniel Sedin second and Henrik Sedin third overall.
Stefan scored just 64 goals and 188 points in 455 games.
17 Alexandre Daigle, 1993
Everyone remembers the 1993 Draft best for the Ottawa Senators badly missing the chance to draft future Hall of Fame defenceman Chris Pronger, opting to take promising forward Alexandre Daigle instead.
Daigle showed potential in his rookie season, scoring 20 goals and 51 points, but just two more 20-goal seasons would follow in the NHL. Daigle would appear in 616 NHL games, scoring 129 goals and 327 points, leaving Senators fans with sour feelings of missing out on taking Pronger, who would win a Norris, Hart Trophy, Stanley Cup, and two Olympic Gold Medals.
16 Bryan Berard, 1995
If it weren’t for a horrific eye injury, Bryan Berard would have had the potential to be a superstar. He was still a great talent in the NHL, but he just didn’t get the chance to be a guy who was worthy of being a first-overall selection.
Despite being drafted by the Senators, he’d never play a game for them. In his second season in the NHL, he scored 14 goals and 46 points with the New York Islanders and even played for Team USA at the 1998 Winter Olympics in Nagano.
His NHL career ended in 2008 and he left the league with 76 goals and 323 points in 619 career games.
15 Joe Murphy, 1986
Joe Murphy was not a draft bust by any means, but considering how Jimmy Carson, Vincent Damphousse, and Brian Leetch went in the top 10, many will overlook the solid career he had.
He won a Stanley Cup in 1990 with the Oilers and, from 1990-91 to 1996-97, he hit the 20-goal mark in six of those seven seasons. Murphy had a very solid all-around career, finishing with 233 goals and 528 points in 779 games.
Considering how weak the 1986 draft class was, there’s no way anyone can justify the selection of Murphy as a poor one.
14 Chris Phillips, 1996
Looking at his statistics, he won’t look like a first-overall pick that avoided the bust label, but Chris Phillips' defensive play, leadership, and ability to lead the Senators consistently into the playoffs cannot be forgotten.
He was one of the most respected players in the NHL during his tenure in the nation’s capital and a fairly-new NHL franchise was taken to new heights right away. Phillips had the chance to leave Ottawa during rebuilding years, but he refused.
Phillips was a fine draft pick for the Senators and surely one of the most iconic players in team history.
13 Roman Hamrlik, 1992
In what was one of the more disappointing drafts in recent memory, Roman Hamrlik stood out from most men in this class.
The all-around defenseman who could succeed at both ends of the ice made it to three All-Star games and guided Czech Republic to a surprising Gold Medal victory at the 1998 Winter Olympics.
Hamrlik’s career in the NHL ended in 2013, finishing with 155 goals and 638 points in 1,395 points. It was definitely a very solid two-decade career for Hamrlik, one of the best from his country to ever play the game.
12 Ed Jovanovski, 1994
‘Jovo’ was one of the most decorated defensemen of his time, but you probably just didn’t notice becuase he played in an era with Nicklas Lidstrom, Scott Niedermayer, Chris Pronger, Rob Blake, and others.
The man who was originally selected by the Panthers played four seasons with the team before going to the Vancouver Canucks, where the league took notice of his name. He became a slick puck-moving defenseman, where he had three 40-point seasons.
Ed Jovanovski, now retired, last played in 2013-14 with the Panthers. He had 500 points in 1,128 points.
11 Vincent Lecavalier, 1998
Though the last five or so seasons of his career were a letdown, considering how huge of a mega star he was years earlier, Vincent Lecavalier was one of the most accomplished players of his generation and the best player in Tampa Bay Lightning history.
Lecavalier led the Lightning to their only Stanley Cup Championship in 2004, scoring 32 goals and 66 points that season. He won the Rocket Richard Trophy in 2007, scoring 52 goals and totalling 108 points during the campaign.
10 Wendel Clark, 1985
One of the most beloved players in Toronto Maple Leafs history, Wendel Clark was a guy you only loved if he was on your team. If he was playing against you, chances are you hated him. But that's a sign he was doing things right.
He played three stints with the Leafs and was always a sure bet to hit near 20 goals. In 793 games, he scored 330 goals and 564 points while making it to a pair of All-Star Games.
Though the Leafs wouldn't win a Cup with Clark, they had struggled long before his arrival. He rejuvenated the fan base throughout the '90s, leading them to the Eastern Conference Final in 1999.
9 Eric Lindros, 1991
Eric Lindros is definitely not going to go down as one of the most popular players of all-time. Such is life when you demand a trade from the Quebec Nordiques who trusted you to be the franchise star of the future.
Eric Lindros was supposed to be the next Wayne Gretzky, but he didn't live up to the hype, in large part due to concussion problems that followed him most of his career. But when he was healthy, it was a whole new story.
The 1995 Hart Trophy winner made it to seven All-Star games, won Olympic Gold with Team Canada at the 2002 Winter Olympics, and was a four-time 40-goal scorer. Lindros retired with a respectable 372 goals and 865 points in 760 games.
8 Owen Nolan, 1990
Before the Joe Thornton-Patrick Marleau era, Owen Nolan was the greatest player in San Jose Sharks history. Drafted by the Nordiques in 1990, he joined San Jose in 1995-96 and the fairly-new franchise didn't wait long to start making noise.
Nolan led the Sharks to the playoffs five-straight years from 1998-2002. A five-time NHL All-Star, he was also part of Canada's 2002 Gold-Medal winning team. In 1,200 games, he managed 422 goals and 885 points, having last played for the Minnesota Wild in 2009-10.
7 Pierre Turgeon, 1987
While you're busy thinking of Wayne Gretzky, Mario Lemieux, Steve Yzerman, Joe Sakic, Sergei Fedorov, Jaromir Jagr, Ron Francis, and other stars dominating the '90s, it's important to remember how just special Pierre Turgeon was.
We're talking about a guy who hit the 100-point mark twice, including a ridiculous 58-74-132 campaign in 1992-93 with the New York Islanders. Turgeon was a star on the Buffalo Sabres, New York Islanders, Montreal Canadiens, and St. Louis Blues.
The 1993 Lady Byng Memorial Trophy winner made it to five All-Star Games and finished with 515 goals and 1,327 points in 1,294 games, reminding us that he was both great and incredibly underrated throughout his career.
6 5. Joe Thornton, 1997
They don't call him 'Jumbo Joe' for nothing.
One of the worst trades in Boston Bruins history involves them trading away their franchise superstar to the San Jose Sharks during the 2005-06 season, and he's simply dominated in the Shark Tank.
Joe Thornton is an assist-machine, reaching 60 assists in a season eight times. He won the Hart Trophy and the Art Ross Trophy after registering 125 points in 2005-06. Thornton has also scored 20-plus goals 11 times, which is remarkable for a player who basically only passes and that's not an exaggeration.
He's won the World Cup of Hockey, an Olympic Gold Medal, and has made it to six All-Star Games. How nice will it be if we get to see him win a Stanley Cup?
4 Mats Sundin, 1989
There are a number of NHL legends who came from Sweden: The Sedin Twins, Daniel Alfredsson, Henrik Zetterberg, Henrik Lundqvist, and Nicklas Lidstrom. None of them stood out like Mats Sundin.
The towering 6-foot-5 centre produced with the Quebec Nordiques, scoring 334 points in his four seasons there. But his legacy was entirely with the Toronto Maple Leafs, where he helped a perennially-struggling franchise become one of the best during the '90s and early 2000s.
Sundin, a nine-time All-Star, won the Olympic Gold Medal in 2006 and made it to the Hockey Hall of Fame in 2012. He finished with 564 goals and 1,349 points in 1,346 games.
3 Dale Hawerchuk, 1981
There was no surprise that he won the Calder Trophy in his rookie year vand Dale Hawerchuk's excellence was just getting started at that point. Hawerchuk had the pressure to perform for the new Winnipeg Jets NHL franchise right away and we assume 85 goals and 194 points in his first two seasons did just that.
In fact, it got better: Hawerchuk reached the 100-point mark in six of his first seven NHL seasons. The Hockey Hall of Famer was a five-time All-Star and finished his career with 518 goals and 1,409 points, which puts him at 19th all-time in league scoring.
2 Mike Modano, 1988
The all-time scoring leader to come from the United States had a dominant career with the Minnesota North Stars/Dallas Stars franchise.
Mike Modano burst onto the scene as a rookie in 1989-90, scoring 29 goals and 75 points. From his rookie season to 2007-08, Modano hit the 20-goal mark in all but two seasons. That's consistency for you.
He hit the 80-point mark eight and won the Stanley Cup with Dallas in 1999.
1 Mario Lemieux, 1984
You can make a case that Mario Lemieux truly is the greatest NHL player to ever live. Yes, some can say he's better than Wayne Gretzky and Gordie Howe. He was truly that special and is a huge icon in Pittsburgh.
The man who appeared in just 915 games (due to injuries and fighting cancer) still managed an incredible 690 goals and 1,723 points. He has the best goals-per-game in BOTH the regular season and playoffs with .750.
The two-time Stanley Cup Champion won three Hart Trophies, six scoring titles, and two Conn Smythe Trophies. He's eighth all-time in league scoring, even though the rest of the top 37 players played at least 1,000 games.
Now, he's enjoying life as a part of Penguins ownership, where he saved the franchise from moving to Las Vegas and helped them win another Stanley Cup in 2009. Super Mario, indeed.
Leave A Comment
Looking for an AD FREE EXPERIENCE on TheSportster?Get Your Free Access Now!