Top 15 Worst Second Generation NHLers

Gordie and Mark Howe. The Griffey's. Dell and Steph. Every professional athlete with a son hopes his boy will follow in his athletic footsteps, while almost every son of a pro hopes to one day emul

Gordie and Mark Howe. The Griffey's. Dell and Steph.

Every professional athlete with a son hopes his boy will follow in his athletic footsteps, while almost every son of a pro hopes to one day emulate their father and carry on the family's legacy.

In some cases, like the Howe's and the Griffey's, the father-son combo gets the unique chance to step out onto the field of play together.

In other cases, the apple does in fact fall far from the tree.

While the sporting world loves to get excited about the offspring of a former star, more often than not the son cannot reach the bar set by his father. This story has played itself out time and time again in the National Hockey League, and while there are plenty of examples where the son outdoes the father - Max Domi is on his way to doing just that - there are just as many, if not more failed second generation NHLers.

Anyone who has ever played any organized form of the sport  knows what hockey dads can be like. The pressure to perform well for one individual can become suffocating - what must it be like when your hockey dad's day job is to score goals for an NHL team? Worse than that: what if you father's day job was to score goals for an NHL team, an NHL team you now play for and are expected to perform equally as well for (if not better)?

It sounds so simple, but it can't always be easy being a second generation NHLer. It certainly wasn't for these individuals (we kept the list to the most notable names).

Continue scrolling to keep reading

Click the button below to start this article in quick view

Start Now

15 Marty Howe (Gordie Howe) 


While Gordie and Mark carved out memorable careers, Marty struggled to first make it to the National Hockey League and then stick there. He finished his career with only 197 games played and 31 total points. The majority of his career was spent in the World Hockey Association and then bouncing between the American Hockey League and the NHL.

Nothing to really scoff at, except for the fact that Marty will also be considered "third" in the list of Howe hockey greatness. While Mark was able to build his own legacy (not quite his father's, mind you), Marty was unable to fully entrench himself into an NHL roster spot.

14 Landon Ferraro (Ray Ferraro) 

Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sports

Here's hoping that Landon is just a late bloomer and that his career is not classified under "minor league journeyman." He's had a few brief shots in the NHL up to this point and is currently hanging on with the Boston Bruins, but he has yet to fully establish himself as a regular NHL roster player. Ray, meanwhile, pilled up 408 goals and 898 points in nearly 1,300 NHL games. It seems unlikely Landon will ever come close that having the same kind of career his father had.

13 Brett Sutter (Darryl Sutter) 

James Guillory-USA TODAY Sports

It's almost easy to forget that Darryl Sutter's son is getting a regular shift in the NHL, what with the fact that it's a lot more interesting to follow the seemingly grudgeful life and times of Darryl Sutter, Los Angeles Kings head coach. The older Sutter had a fine NHL career and is now the proud owner of two Cup rings as a head coach.

Brett, meanwhile, has struggled finding his way in the NHL and up to this point has only appeared in 60 games, putting up 10 points in that time. At 28 years old, Sutter's window of opportunity may be drawing to a close before he can ever truly get a chance to try and match his father's achievements.

12 Jarred Tinordi (Mark Tinordi) 

Matt Kartozian-USA TODAY Sports

Montreal Canadiens fans waited a long, long time for Jarred Tinordi to get a fair shake with the Habs.

He never did.

Now, Tinordi's legacy will always be remembered mainly by the fact that he was a small part of the John Scott fiasco that engulfed the league's All-Star Weekend, as opposed to being the brawn on a defensive pairing with either Nathan Beaulieu or P.K. Subban for the next decade. Tinordi was seemingly incapable of fully settling into the pace of play in the NHL, nor did he ever seem comfortable playing under a coaching staff that has little to no patience for the growing pains of young players.

All that said, Tinordi never really "wowed" anyone of his own accord, either, save for a few big hits and some decent fights. He'll get another shot in Arizona, but don't expect him to come close to matching the reliable and sturdy career his father, Mark, had with the North Stars and the Capitals.

11 Nick Vachon (Rogie Vachon) 


Rogie Vachon is something of a "legend" in Quebec, insomuch that he gets a bit of a different treatment than most of the top goalies to play for the Canadiens have gotten over the years. Roy, Dryden and Plante (and maybe one day Price) were and still are revered by Habs fans. Vachon's spot in history comes with a more divisive conversation, but there was no doubting his talent. He racked up 355 wins in 795 games to go along with a career 2.99 goals against average and 51 shutouts.

His son, Nicholas, played one NHL game at left wing for the New York Islanders. He's likely better known for his role in a 2003 short hockey film Clark: The Canadian Hockey Goalie.

10 Marcus Foligno (Mike Foligno) 

Sergei Belski-USA TODAY Sports

Mike Foligno was not only known for being a decent hockey player - he's fondly remembered for his jumping celebration every time he put the puck in the net.

His oldest son, Nick, has had plenty of reason to jump for joy during his NHL career (in terms of individual statistics, at least), especially over the last couple of years.

Marcus? Not as much. While the younger Foligno will likely top his career high in points this year (he's sitting on 15 points right now and his career high is 20 points, by the way), he was never able to develop into much more than a grinding winger on a bad Buffalo team. Marcus is one of the few who's had the privilege of playing for the same team as their father, but it's safe to say no Sabres fans are confusing him with his dad when he's on the ice.

9 Terry Clancy (King Clancy) 


Growing up as the son of an NHL legend and the man who played all six positions in a single NHL game can't be easy, especially if you have aspirations to follow in those massive footsteps. Terry Clancy tried, but he could never match what his father, King, was able to do in the NHL. King Clancy now has a trophy named after him, while Terry only played 93 NHL games, in which he only put up 12 points. The Clancy name will remain one of the most respected in the hockey world, but that reputation is carried on the first generation's shoulders alone.

8 Gerry Abel (Sid Abel) 


Sid Abel did it all in the National Hockey League. He played in 612 NHL games and put up 472 points, he coached the Red Wings to four Stanley Cup Finals (and lost them all, unfortunately) and 382 wins, and even worked as a general manager for a time before turning to the broadcasting booth. Abel was even, at one time, considered one of the top 100 players of all-time by The Hockey News.

His son, Gerry, didn't make quite as much of an impact on the league as his father did. Gerry only suited up for one NHL game for the Red Wings. He retired from hockey one year later.

7 Keegan Lowe (Kevin Lowe) 

James Guillory-USA TODAY Sports

Keegan Lowe hasn't truly had an extended shot to show what he can do at the NHL level, and it seems unlikely for the time being that the son of former Oiler Kevin Lowe will ever make the mark on the NHL that his father did back in the 1980s. The younger Lowe's claim to fame up to this point was a quick two game stint in the pros. In one of those games, Lowe dropped the gloves twice with Vincent Lecavalier. The younger Lowe still has time to perform his way off this list, but, to this point, he's proven to be a career AHLer with a knack for fighting.

6 Tim Erixon (Jan Erixon) 

Aaron Doster-USA TODAY Sports

Jan Erixon earned the nickname "The Shadow" for his elite ability to cover the opposition's top players. Tim Erixon, on the other hand, will eventually end up with a nickname that will reference his now lengthy trade history.

The younger Erixon has never been able to stick around one team for awhile, often being thrown in as an add on to trades and bouncing back and forth between the pros and the minors.

5 Sam Gagner (Dave Gagner) 

Eric Hartline-USA TODAY Sports

Sam Gagner exploded onto the scene not only because of his incredible talent and his seemingly complete offensive game - he also caught the attention of many around the league thanks to his slick hands and incredible one-on-one ability in the shootout.

It seems this got the Oilers a little too excited, who picked Gagner sixth overall in the 2007 draft and proceeded to slot him directly into their NHL lineup.

Gagner showed promise but ultimately was never able to live up to the high expectations, and at this rate it's highly unlikely that the younger Gagner will be able to catch up to his father's scoring totals.

4 John Ferguson Jr. (John Ferguson Sr.) 


John Ferguson Sr. was not only one of the most respected and feared players of his era, he was also an effective hockey player and later on dabbled in coaching. He left behind a legacy for his son to continue to carry after he was drafted by the Montreal Canadiens, the same team his father patrolled for during his prime as an enforcer.

The younger Ferguson was never able to make as impactful of a mark on the game as his father. He never laced up for an NHL game and his AHL career was a short-lived one - and that's without mentioning his foray into management.

3 Steve Gainey (Bob Gainey) 


While the Gainey name took a bit of a hit during the tail-end of Bob Gainey's tenure as general manager of the Habs, his reputation as a player and a leader will never be tarnished. Gainey led the Habs to five cups and wore the "C" for nearly a decade.

His son, Steve, had lofty expectations to live up to and was never able to come remotely close. He was actually drafted by his father, but only totaled 33 NHL games as he bounced around the professional hockey world for over a decade.

2 Dan Geoffrion (Bernie Geoffrion)  


Living in the shadow of a man who not only became a Montreal Canadiens icon, but also invented a major aspect of the sport as we know it, can't be easy for anyone - but Dan Geoffrion's story was supposed to be different. Drafted 8th overall by the Habs in 1978, Geoffrion was supposed to pick up where his father left off all those years ago - if not surpass his dad on the list of Canadiens greats.

Instead, Geoffrion turned into a draft bust, playing only one season in Montreal and only lasting 111 games in the NHL before finishing off his career in the minors.

1 Chris Bourque (Ray Bourque) 


While no one was expected Chris Bourque to come anywhere close to matching his father's legendary career, the expectation was that Bourque would develop into a solid NHL player.

Fast-forward a decade after his name was called at the 2004 draft and Chris Bourque has solidified his label as a JAG: just a guy. Bourque has only appeared in 51 career NHL games and has spent his entire career as a minor-league journeyman. He even ventured over to Europe and eventually the KHL during parts of his career.

Give TheSportster a Thumbs up!

Looking for an AD FREE EXPERIENCE on TheSportster?

Get Your Free Access Now!

More in NHL

Top 15 Worst Second Generation NHLers