TheSportster.com

Ranking WrestleMania Main Event Winners From Worst To Best

The greatest achievement one can accomplish in the WWE is being in the main event of a WrestleMania show. There are a handful of World Champions crowned each year with the number growing due to the brand split needing two title holders at the top of the company. World Champions are still important, but the main event of WrestleMania is truly the greatest honor of the year. It shows WWE trusts these performers to be in the spotlight to represent the company. The financial bonus that comes along with it shows just how valued the main eventers of the biggest show of the year are by the WWE.

One of the major reasons CM Punk was frustrated during his time in the WWE before leaving was the fact that he felt he deserved the opportunity to main event WrestleMania. Punk had numerous top level matches on the biggest show of the year, but never closed the show with the biggest match of the night. That sums up how important the accomplishment is. As of this writing, there have been thirty-two WrestleMania events with nineteen men holding victories in the final match of the show. We will rank them each from worst to best, listing every man to ever win a WrestleMania main event match.

19 Lawrence Taylor (WM XI)

via wwe.com

The worst wrestler to win a WrestleMania main event is naturally someone that wasn’t even a wrestler. WWE tried to get mainstream coverage for the event by having former NFL Superstar Lawrence Taylor wrestle at the big event. The most unlikely of WrestleMania main events came at WrestleMania XI when Taylor squared off against Bam Bam Bigelow. NFL stars surrounded the ring on Taylor’s behalf and heel wrestlers did the same for Bigelow.

18 Mr. T (WM I)

via wwe.com

The first WrestleMania event featured a lot of celebrity involvement and it led to another example of a celebrity winning a main event. Mr. T developed a good relationship with Hulk Hogan following their time working together on the set of Rocky III. Vince McMahon knew he needed the star power to sell the WrestleMania concept to the public. It led to the team of Hogan and Mr. T facing Roddy Piper and Paul Orndorff in the main event of WrestleMania I.

17 Roman Reigns (WM 32)

via wrestleview.com

We find the first wrestler on the list for the most recent of WrestleMania events. Roman Reigns has been the centerpiece of the WWE for a few years now. The big, crowning moment for Reigns becoming “The Guy” to lead the WWE into the future was supposed to come at WrestleMania 32 against Triple H. It was technically the biggest wrestling show of all-time based off the crowd size, which stood at a record breaking 100,000+ fans in attendance.

16 The Miz (WM XXVII)

photos.toofab.com

The greatest accomplishment of The Miz’s career is being able to say he defeated John Cena in the main event of WrestleMania XXVII to retain the WWE Championship. Sadly, many fans forget he was even involved in the match. The main event surrounded the story of The Rock and John Cena. Rock attacked Cena to unintentionally help The Miz win the match. It was all to set up the future WrestleMania main events between The Rock and Cena.

15 The Rock (WM XXVIII)

via wwe.com

The Rock has been in five WrestleMania main events, but only holds one victory in those matches. Rock’s earlier years saw him lose to Steve Austin (twice) and Triple H in the biggest matches of the year. It wasn’t until WrestleMania XXVIII that The Rock would achieve his first and only win in the main event of a WrestleMania show over John Cena.

14 Batista (WM 21)

via cagesideseats.com

WrestleMania 21 featured a changing of the guard. John Cena defeated JBL earlier in the night to win the WWE Championship for the SmackDown brand. The main event saw Batista do the same with a victory over Triple H to capture Raw’s World Heavyweight Championship. Batista and Cena were new stars with The Animal reaching the top of the mountain following a long storyline leading to a huge moment.

13 Bret Hart (WM X)

via prorasslin.files.wordpress.com

The legendary Bret Hart had some of the greatest matches in WrestleMania history against Steve Austin, Shawn Michaels, and Owen Hart. Unfortunately, the only WrestleMania main event victory for Bret turned out to be one of the weaker main events in the history of the show. Hart defeated Yokozuna to win the WWE Championship at WrestleMania X in Madison Square Garden.

12 Brock Lesnar (WM XIX)

via cagesideseats.com

One of the better bell to bell main events in WrestleMania history saw Brock Lesnar defeat Kurt Angle for the WWE Championship at WrestleMania XIX. Both men left it all in the ring for a hard hitting contest based around the pure wrestling styles of the competitors. Angle and Lesnar both wrestled an outstanding match and sadly left with injuries. Lesnar botched a shocking moment, which saw him fail to hit a Shooting Star Press and land on his head.

11 Randy Savage (WM IV)

via youtube.com

Randy Savage always appeared to be in the shadow of Hulk Hogan when it came to the upper echelon of the WWE in the 80s. WrestleMania IV saw him finally get the opportunity to be the man on top of the card. Savage was the first person aside from Hogan to win a WrestleMania main event when he defeated Ted DiBiase in the finals of a tournament to determine the new WWE Champion.

10 Triple H (WM 2000, X8 & XXV)

via wikimedia.org

The wrestlers to win multiple WrestleMania main events are towards the top of the list, but Triple H is ranked lower due to the disappointment associated with his matches. Triple H retained the WWE Championship at WrestleMania 2000 in a forgettable Fatal-Four-Way Match that revolved around McMahon family drama, overshadowing him. The other two main events were even more disappointing.

Triple H returned from a long injury stint in 2002 to win the Royal Rumble and defeat Chris Jericho to capture the WWE Undisputed Championship. It was meant to be a huge moment but their lackluster match was outshined by The Rock and Hulk Hogan stealing the show.

9 Seth Rollins (WM 31)

via pintrest.com

It almost feels wrong ranking Seth Rollins this high considering he only spent about a minute or so in an actual WrestleMania main event. The WrestleMania 31 main event was technically Roman Reigns challenging Brock Lesnar for the WWE World Championship. Rollins used his Money in the Bank contract to cash in towards the end, making it a Triple Threat Match and capturing the top prize in the sport.

8 Chris Benoit (WM XX)

via lutte.quebec

Chris Benoit's wrestling career featured a library of classic matches. One stands out as the high point of his WWE tenure, which took place when he defeated Triple H and Shawn Michaels in the main event of WrestleMania XX to win the World Championship. Benoit winning the Royal Rumble still left many unconvinced the WWE would actually put him over their two top stars at the time.

7 The Ultimate Warrior (WM VI)

via pintrest.com

You can count the wrestlers that cleanly defeated Hulk Hogan during the Hulkamania era in the WWE on one hand. The most high profile Hogan loss came at WrestleMania VI in a battle between the two most popular wrestlers in the WWE at the time. The Ultimate Warrior progressed into a new fan favorite starting to challenge Hogan as the top star in the company.

6 Daniel Bryan (WM XXX)

via inquisitr.com

The most improbable WrestleMania main event victory turned out to be one of the best. Daniel Bryan became the most beloved wrestler on the roster, but the WWE continued to hold him down. His look and size saw the WWE want to go with a main event of Randy Orton against Batista instead. Fans rejected both men every week leading into the show and basically forced Bryan into the main event of WrestleMania XXX.

5 Shawn Michaels (WM XII)

via wwe.com

If this list was about the wrestlers most valuable to WrestleMania history, Shawn Michaels would be number one, but he somehow only won one main event at the biggest show of the year. Michaels had outstanding performances in four other WrestleMania main events, but took losses to the likes of Steve Austin, Chris Benoit, John Cena and The Undertaker.

4 John Cena (WM 22, 23, 29)

via thearmbarexpress.files.wordpress.com

John Cena's dominance has seen him hold down the fort as the face of the WWE for the past decade. No one has been able to surpass or even match him. Cena’s run has seen him main event WrestleMania five times with three victories. The wins for Cena to close WrestleMania have seen him take down iconic names like Triple H, Shawn Michaels and The Rock.

3 Steve Austin (WM XIV, XV, X-Seven)

via tumblr.com

Steve Austin’s hot streak in wrestling can be looked at through the timeline of his WrestleMania matches. His tenure as the top star in the industry started at WrestleMania 13 against Bret Hart and ended when he retired against The Rock at WrestleMania XIX. Neither of those matches were main events, but Austin piled up a few in-between.

2 Hulk Hogan (WM I, 2, III, V, VII, VIII, IX)

via bleacherreport.net

The man with the most WrestleMania main event victories is still Hulk Hogan and that will be difficult to top. Hogan was involved in eight of the first nine WrestleMania main events, winning seven of those matches. The most memorable wins for Hogan came at WrestleMania III defeating Andre the Giant in a landmark moment for the WWE and topping fellow iconic Superstar Randy Savage at WrestleMania V in another huge bout.

The rest of Hogan’s main events all have some strong flaws attached to them. Hogan definitely played the biggest factor on screen when it came to WrestleMania becoming such a huge success. However, he clearly overstayed his welcome and contributed to some of the worst WrestleMania main events.

1 The Undertaker (WM 13, XXIV, XXVI)

via joniscarpolini.files.wordpress.com

The undefeated streak of The Undertaker lasting over two decades may be the most impressive statistic anyone will ever have at WrestleMania. However, The Undertaker has surprisingly only had three main event matches at WrestleMania with victories in all of them. WrestleMania 13 featured The Undertaker finally being elevated as the top face by defeating Sycho Sid to win the WWE Championship. The match wasn’t great, but the moment was special for all 90s fans.

The Undertaker continued his dominance eleven years later with a World Championship over Edge at the height of his undefeated streak to close out WrestleMania XXIV. His most memorable win would have to be WrestleMania XXVI, when he defeated Shawn Michaels in a legendary bout that ended up being the retirement match of Michaels career. It summed up everything that WrestleMania has become with the passion showing in the art of wrestling.

Give TheSportster a Thumbs up!

Looking for an AD FREE EXPERIENCE on TheSportster?

Get Your Free Access Now!

More in Wrestling

Ranking WrestleMania Main Event Winners From Worst To Best